The museum's design was contested before it even opened. In December 1956, while construction was still underway, twenty-one painters, including Willem de Kooning, Adolph Gottlieb, Philip Guston, Franz Kline and Robert Motherwell, published an open letter to the museum's director and trustees arguing that Wright's tilted, curving walls and skylit ramp would work against the paintings the building existed to show, making canvases hard to hang and see correctly. The dispute did not end there: when Thomas Messer became director in 1961, staff still had to build specially angled plinths to compensate for the curved walls, and one Alexander Calder mobile could never be made to hang level in the space. Wright himself held that the design gave painting a more unified, sympathetic setting than a conventional box gallery, and over time curators found the ramp's continuous flow suited large, immersive exhibitions the traditional format could not, so the very features the painters objected to are now often cited as the building's defining strength.
The Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum is the New York museum Frank Lloyd Wright designed for the collector Solomon R. Guggenheim to house his foundation's collection of non-objective and modern painting. Wright was hired in June 1943 and spent the next fifteen years revising the design through more than 700 sketches and six full sets of working drawings before construction finally began in August 1956; the building opened in October 1959, six months after Wright's own death, and the interior spiral ramp he designed remains the museum's defining architectural feature, a continuous helical gallery lit from a domed skylight rather than a sequence of conventional rooms. It was Wright's last major work and is now among the most visited museums in the world.
Facts
Location1071 Fifth Avenue, Manhattan, New York City, United States 1 Architectural StyleModernist organic architecture, built around an inverted ziggurat-like continuous spiral ramp rather than a sequence of separate rooms. 1 Structural SystemThe helical ramp itself acts as a continuous structural arch, bracing the columns of the main gallery against collapsing inward; concrete ribs reinforce and divide the ramp into sections. 1 Primary MaterialReinforced concrete ramp structure, gunite sprayed-concrete facade finished in an ivory-colored coating. 1 Building Type Commissioned BySolomon R. Guggenheim and Hilla Rebay, director of his foundations collection of non-objective painting 1 ConstructionWright was engaged in 1943; ground was broken August 14, 1956 after fifteen years of design revisions and over 700 preliminary sketches. UNESCO Inscription YearOne of eight Wright buildings inscribed together as The 20th-Century Architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright. Current UseActive art museum, displaying Impressionist, Post-Impressionist, modern and contemporary art 1 Visitor AccessOpen to the public as a ticketed museum 1 Cross-Tradition Connections
Created By
In Form
In Movement
In the Other Atlases
Sources
Dissenting Readings (1 dissenting reading)
Structural System
In December 1956, while the Guggenheim was still under construction, twenty-one painters published an open letter to the museum's director, James Johnson Sweeney, and its trustees, arguing that Wright's spiral ramp and skylight worked against, not for, the paintings the museum existed to show: the tilted, curving walls made canvases hard to hang and to see correctly, and light flooding down the ramp would compete with light meant to fall on the art itself. The dispute did not end at opening. When the museum's director Thomas Messer arrived in 1961, the building's ability to present artwork was still doubted, sculpture in particular, since the slope of the floor and the curve of the wall together could produce genuine optical distortion, and staff resorted to specially angled plinths to compensate; one Alexander Calder mobile could never be made to hang level in the space. Wright's own reply, published as a rebuttal, held that the building was designed to give painting a more sympathetic, unified setting than a conventional box gallery, not a hostile one, and later curators have argued the criticized features became the design's strength once large-scale, immersive shows became the norm the space was suited to.
A dissenting reading, from Twenty-one New York painters, including Willem de Kooning, Adolph Gottlieb, Philip Guston, Franz Kline and Robert MotherArchives of American Art, Smithsonian Institution, Smithsonian Institution
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.